U.S. prosecturos have asked a Miami judge to sentence Charles McArthur Emmanuel — son of the former president of Liberia — to 147 years in prison for torturing prisoners when he was a paramilitary leader in Liberia. It’s being done under a 1994 act that makes it possible to try people in the US for torture committed overseas.
The funny part, of course, is that Bush’s own Justice Department is describing torture as a “flagrant and pernicious abuse of power and authority … It undermines respect for and trust in authority, government and a rule of law (and) the gravity of the offense of torture is beyond dispute.” Funny because our own government has been doing it since 9/11 with Bush’s sanction (Emmanuel has actually argued that he shouldn’t be prosecuted when Americans have committed the same crimes in Iraq). Funny because the current Attorney General has ruled out any investigation or prosecution for CIA agents who’ve used torture, on grounds including that it wouldn’t be fair if previous AGs had told them it was OK (even if that advice rose to the level of criminal negligence).
Don’t get me wrong, if Taylor’s guilty, he deserves a harsh sentence, and I’ll be happy if he gets it. But if our government sanctioned torture—and the evidence is clear that it did—there’s no reason our leaders shouldn’t face the same. The pretense that torture is completely different and justified when we do it isn’t funny at all.



